Do you remember the anger and frustration that you and so many of your fellow countrymen felt on Election Day 2009? We were all angry and frustrated because of the long lines. We were all angry and frustrated that too many polling places didn't open on time.
The UPP Government feels your frustration and wants change - the ALP wants more of the same. The Antigua Sun reports:
The Antigua and Barbuda Labour Party (ALP) is condemning statements made by the prime minister concerning the Antigua and Barbuda Electoral Commission (ABEC) and their handling of the 2009 General Elections.
Prime Minister Baldwin Spencer at a town hall meeting in Piggott’s last Thursday (22 April) said the ruling of Justice Louise Blenman, that the late opening of the polls on Election Day (12 March) falls squarely at the feet of members of the Electoral Commission. The PM said that some action needed to be taken to avoid a reoccurrence of the situation.
One member of the five-member commission, Agnes Blaize, as a result of what was said tendered her resignation to Governor General Dame Louise Lake-Tack earlier this week.
The ALP said it is not pleased with what the prime minister’s call for members of the commission to resign and for the "supervisor of elections to demit office immediately."
It's outrageous that the ALP is defending the Electoral Commission. Do they not remember the long lines, the late openings and the anger and frustration that so many of us felt? Do they think that by leaving the same people in charge and not holding anyone accountable for their failure that we're going to change things? Ridiculous.
Of course we understand, honour and respect the independence of the Electoral Commission. But, we also believe in the simple notion of accountability. If you don't do your job properly, your boss will hold you accountable. It's clear that the Electoral Commission didn't do their jobs properly. But, it doesn't seem that the ALP wants to hold anyone accountable for their failure. How typical.
The UPP Government is ensuring that professionals in Antigua & Barbuda have the highest quality training so that they can provide the highest quality service to our people. That's why the UPP Government is reaching out and securing opportunities for Antiguans and Barbudans to receive advanced training that will help them further their careers and improve the quality of service on our islands.
To that end, we're pleased to announce that six Antiguans & Barbudans were selected to participate in special training opportunities in Japan. The professionals include:
Darez Dundas - Education in Science and Mathematics in Primary School
Daryl Spencer - Waste Management Techniques and Environment Education
Karen Cabrall - Japanese Programme for Foreign Service Offices
Natasha George - Japanese Programme for Young Diplomats and
Sherese George, a teacher of the Ottos Comprehensive School is presently on the Japanese Teaching Exchange 2009/2010. This program allows Miss George to teach English to Japanese students.
The most recent selection, announced this week, is Valerie Browne Williams, a nurse.
The students are participating in a programme sponsored by the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), which was established on August 1974, with a view to contributing towards world peace and prosperity through its economic cooperation programmes. The UPP Government will continue to work with our international allies to identify more programmes like this that provide opportunities to our young people and improve the quality of life in Antigua & Barbuda.
Tomorrow, the UPP Government is kicking off our Island Beautification Campaign. This campaign is focused on making our island more attractive and appealing for our people and our tourists. This island wide cleanup will promote a spirit of community conservation and encourage people to take care of our precious island.
This campaign will be cleaning up communities across Antigua. We're starting with the Grace Green Community. Tomorrow, we will plant trees in the area and Saturday we will conduct a community cleanup.
Join us tomorrow at 10 am at the Multi Purpose Cultural Centre for the tree planting and on Saturday at 7 pm at the King George V grounds for the community clean up. Please contact Vashti Ramsey at 463-9522/23 for more information. We hope you can join us!
Prime Minister Baldwin Spencer participated in the first ever CARICOM-Brazil Summit where he met with his Brazilian counterpart, President Luiz Inácio "Lula" da Silva. Much was accomplished at the meeting. The two leaders discussed stronger trading ties, educational opportunities for Antiguans & Barbudans, investment opportunities, energy cooperation, technology assistance and more. Prime Minsiter Spencer:
At this meeting CARICOM intends to establish a formal and structural relationship with Brazil. This meeting comes at an opportune time as Brazil enjoys significant influence in the region, Latin American and most importantly in the hemisphere where it has become a privileged interlocutor of the United States. So we intend to strengthen our relations with Brazil while at the same time increasing joint actions for our mutual benefit. Greater integration between CARICOM and Latin America can be forged at this meeting and at the same time we can achieve better levels of commercial, cultural, social and economic development.
On a personal level, Antigua and Barbuda will sign a visa-waiver agreement with Brazil which will exempt holders of Diplomatic and Official passports from requiring visas to enter Brazil. We will also sign an agreement for technical cooperation in Education and Sports. Since my administration came into office, we have been forging close relations which Brazil which has resulted in us establishing a Consulate in that country and Brazil establishing an Embassy here. We are very pleased with the progress of cooperation between our two countries.
While the previous ALP regime snubbed their nose at and alienated the international community Prime Minister Baldwin Spencer is continuing his tradition of responsible leadership by building alliances that will ultimately benefit our people.
They say that facts are stubborn things. And, when you look at the facts regarding voting patterns and participation in St. George, St. John's Rural North and St. John's Rural West, it's clear that they mirrored the rest of the country. Everett Christian writes in CaribArena:
Now, for a closer look at the voting pattern during the 2009 elections: As intimated above, the average voter turn-out in 2009 was 80.27%. The turn-out in the three constituencies, where the election results have been voided, is as follows:
* St. John’s Rural West – 80.48% which is marginally above the national average.
* St. John’s Rural North – 79.03%, which is 1% below the national average, and
* St. George – 79.02%, which is also 1% below the national average.For the record, the turn-out in these constituencies was not only in line with the national average, but they exceeded the turnout in several other constituencies, including:
* St. John’s Rural South, which had a voter turn-out of 76.36%, which you will note is 3.91% below the national average, and
* St. Mary’s North, which recorded a voter turn-out of 77.84%, which is 2.43% below the national average.When these figures are examined, it is impossible to comprehend how it could be suggested or construed that persons were disenfranchised, and to the extent that it would have a bearing on the outcome of the election of the candidates involved. In my humble opinion, Justice Blenman erred, and significantly so, when she confined her comparison only to the voter turn-out in 2009 vs. 2004; and once the premise of the judgment is false, the result is bound to be flawed. To use a local saying, one has to compare apples with apples; not apples with oranges, and that is precisely what Justice Blenman did when she used the 2004 turn-out as the basis for arriving at her decision. Not only was the learned lady comparing apples with oranges but she did so in a year when the list was not “clean” - hence a double whammy, as the trends clearly demonstrate that the voter turn-out when the electoral list in not clean is significantly lower.
Had Justice Blenman done the math, she would have gleaned from the above statistics that the percentage voter turnout in 2009 was the highest in Antigua’s history of elections with unclean lists. Remarkable but factual! With the benefit of this knowledge, the learned Judge would have been bound to deliver a ruling contrary to the one she did.
Mr. Christian goes on to create a hypothetical and concludes that even in the most favourable scenario for the ALP, the UPP, the UPP would still be the majority party in Parliament. Mr. Christian:
Another factor that was most likely overlooked by the Judge, is that the highest voter turn-out in Antigua was in the constituency of St. Philip North (which is one of the smaller constituencies in terms of the number of registered electors), where the turnout was 85.06%. Even if, for the sake of argument, the Judge were to decide that the turn-out in the three affected constituencies should be at least 85.06% (and this reasoning could not withstand scrutiny) this would have the following effect:
* The number of voters in St. John’s Rural West would increase by 229 to 4,250
* The number of voters in Rural North would increase by 216 votes to 3,043, and
* The number of voters in St. George would increase by 267 to 3,755.Further, if hypothetically all of the new votes were awarded to the ALP, the UPP would still be declared the winner in St. John’s Rural West and St. George, where the margin of victory was 506 votes and 502 votes respectively. Only in the case of St. John’s Rural North would the result be different, as the margin of victory was 79 votes, compared to the 216 additional voters.
The point that screams loudest in all this is that, despite whatever permutation is used, the UPP would still be the majority party in Parliament. This is as simple as ABC or 1-2-3. The decision of Justice Blenman, which according to her was based on a comparison of historical data, defies mathematical logic, since fairness demanded that a much broader approach be used rather than just the data from the previous election. My analysis bears this out. The UPP is therefore more than justified in its decision to appeal to a higher Court. In the interest of equity, fair-play and natural justice, this flawed judgement should be overturned if all the facts and historical statistics are taken into account.
Facts are stubborn things. And, the facts show that the people had their say and the UPP clearly won the 2009 election.
Prominent UK attorney Phillip Bree cited specific legal arguments that make it clear that Justice Louise Blenman erred in her recent decision. CaribArena reports:
The UK attorney said Justice Blenman misinterpreted case law in arriving at her decision.
In the Edgell v Glover case, Bree pointed out there was a one-vote difference between the candidates “and it was known for a fact that one of the postal votes had been counted illegally.”
“In my view, neither the facts nor the conclusions of the High Court in Edgell have any authoritative or persuasive bearing on the case before Blenman J," he said. "She was wrong to derive any legal test from Edgell; let alone to make it the bedrock of her decision-making."
He added that in the legal test set out in another case, Morgan v Simpson, the petitioner was obliged to show that the outcome of the election was a travesty or sham. But he said instead, Justice Blenman “watered down her decision-making to the legal equivalent of a shrug of the shoulders”.
Bree said the judge in effect reversed the burden of proof, placing it on the respondents.
“Further, by requiring the respondents to show that there was no effect on the outcome, the respondents are being asked to prove a negative,” he added. “The role of the courts in matters of constitutional significance is to take into account the public interest. Blenman J’s capricious approach has led to a severe constitutional crisis."
Read the full opinion. The UPP Team is appealing because we believe that justice must be done. It's clear from Mr. Bree's legal arguments that major errors were made in the reading of the law. For the sake of future grievances in Antigua & Barbuda and across our region, it is our obligation to make sure that the justice system gets the law right.
The UPP Government are competent managers of the debt created largely from the disastrous financial management of the previous ALP regime. CaribArena reports:
According to a release issued last night, IMF "Deputy Managing Director Murilo Portugal, said the programme being pursued by Antigua and Barbuda is impressive and assured Minister Lovell of the Fund’s continued support as Antigua and Barbuda seeks to emerge from the shock of the global economic and financial crises."
The UPP Government was dealt a tough hand. We were dealt a mountain of debt from the corrupt and incompetent ALP regime. And, we had to deal with the disastrous consequences of the global economic crisis. While there's still much work to do, after years of mismanagement, we finally have this country on the right track and headed in the right direction.
The previous ALP Government plunged Antigua & Barbuda into massive debt and the UPP Government is working to clean up their mess. When it comes to debt management, the UPP Government has us on the right trick, heading in the right direction. Later this week, Finance Minister Harold Lovell will travel to Washington DC to hold a series of meetings to discuss Antigua and Barbuda's comprehensive debt management strategy. The team will meet with investors and creditors to discuss how the global financial crisis has affected our country.
The UPP is taking action to bring the crippling debt left by the corrupt ALP regime under control. The ALP seeks to turn the clock back. Their reckless policy would thumb our nose at the international community and wreck our economy. We can't afford the ALP's recklessness. We must continue to support the sensible and smart economic policies of the United Progressive Party government.
Jacqui Quinn-Leandro isn't letting her campaign bus sit idle - she's using it to help seniors in her constituency. CaribArena reports:
St Georges MP Dr Jacqui Quinn-Leandro continued the bi-weekly bus tour/excursion for senior citizens and constituents on Sunday.
“During the elections, we acquired a bus for the campaign, and instead of having the bus out of service we have decided to use it for excursions, to take the senior citizens and young people on tours,” the representative said...
Quinn-Leandra said the excursion gives residents, especially the senior citizens, the chance to re-connect with the country and unwind from the politics of the week.
Your UPP MPs and constituency representatives aren't letting up. We're continuing to take action to improve the lives of people across Antigua.
Prime Minister Baldwin Spencer is continuing the work of governing this country. That work includes building and cultivating relationships with key allies in the region. Building strong alliances helps us attract investment and goods to our nation. Prime Minister Spencer:
It is my intention to build on the close relations that currently exist between Antigua and Barbuda and the Government of Venezuela, particularly our relations as it relates to our involvement in ALBA. Antigua and Barbuda has benefited tremendously from our involvement in ALBA and by extension our relations with Venezuela and it is my belief that strengthening the relations can only be of mutual benefit to both of our countries.
Prime Minister Spencer believes in putting the interests of the people of Antigua & Barbuda first. Our membership in this alliance provides investment and resources that help us prosper.